pork butt tacos

7 Fall-Apart Tender Pork Butt Recipe Ideas to Enjoy

Last Updated on April 11, 2022

Pork butt is an unbelievably versatile cut of meat. There are so many pork butt recipes out there, it can be hard to choose. That’s because it works as a roast, for pulled pork, and responds well to virtually any flavor profile.

It’s a barbecue classic, but it has many other uses, thanks to its rich marbling and plenty of connective tissue for added flavor.

You can, of course, douse it in your favorite BBQ sauce—we’ve got pork butt recipes for that! But, you could also prep an Italian-inspired roast with fennel and tomato or use it as the carnitas filling for flavorful lettuce wraps.

Fun fact: While dubbed pork “butt,” this cut actually hails from the shoulder. The misnomer dates back to colonial America when New England butchers used to pack this cut into barrels called “butts.”

The ideal way to prepare pork butt involves low and slow cooking, along with plenty of moisture. We’ve got lots of pork butt recipes to get you started, so read on.

You might be wondering what to do with pork butt. Here are seven pork butt recipes that use this versatile meat.

1 – Cumin and Orange Pork Butt Recipe

cumin and orange marinated pork butt

This pork butt recipe is bursting with flavors. From citrus to smoke to spice, it has it all.

Packed with Latin-inspired flair, this cumin and orange pork butt recipe is a simple dinner that tastes anything but.

Cumin adds distinctive spice to the dish, while an orange juice braise lends beautiful acidity and slight sweetness. Beyond those two ingredients, you’ll only need your pork butt, a few more spices, whole oranges, and onions.

The preparation is just as simple. Just dry rub your pork, and then braise with orange juice, whole orange, and onion. Make sure you don’t forget to take a basting break, however.

  • 8 Ingredients
  • Total Time: 3 Hours 10 Minutes

2 – Fennel and Tomato Italian Pork Butt Recipe

Jumping from Latin-inspired to Italian-inspired, this fennel and tomato Italian pork butt recipe has Sunday night dinner written all over it.

This wholesome meal is made even better by its uber-simple prep: Just dump everything in the slow cooker, and let those beautiful flavors marry all day long. The only other step? A quick sear of your pork butt, along with a sauté of a few veggies and aromatics.

We’re talking fresh bulbs of fennel,  garlic cloves, tomatoes, and balsamic vinegar. Yes, your home will smell heavenly while this cooks.

  • 11 Ingredients
  • Total Time: 5 Hours 10 Minutes
  • Diet: Dairy Free, Gluten Free, Keto, Paleo, Whole30

3 – Smoky Coffee Rubbed Pulled Pork Recipe

coffee-rubbed pulled pork

You use a blend of coffee grounds and other spices to make this pork butt recipe.

You’ve had pulled pork before, but not like this smoky coffee rubbed pulled pork recipe.

If you haven’t thought to rub down your pork butt with coffee before, let this recipe convince you. Coffee adds a slightly bitter flavor that melds wonderfully with the rest of the dry rub, including chipotle powder, smoked paprika, ground ginger, mustard powder, ground coriander, brown sugar, and salt.

You’ll braise this incredibly flavorful pulled pork in apple cider and onion. Here’s a pro-tip to achieving fall-apart tender meat: Cook your pork butt low and slow with plenty of moisture. Steam is crucial to a tender, juicy texture.

  • 11 Ingredients
  • Total Time: 1 Day 4 Hours
  • Diet: Dairy Free, Gluten Free, Paleo

4 – Keto BBQ Pulled Pork Recipe

Craving sweet and sticky pulled pork, but trying to keep keto? We’ve got you covered with this Keto BBQ pulled pork recipe.

Did we mention it’s a 4-ingredient recipe? While simple and straightforward, no flavor is sacrificed. You’ll combine your pork butt with your preferred sugar-free, keto-friendly barbecue sauce. Onions and garlic add even more savory flavor.

You have two options for preparing this uber-simple pulled pork. Dump it in the slow cooker for an all-day braise, or you can pressure cook it in your Instant Pot for fork-tender pulled pork in a fraction of the time.

Pile this pulled pork high on some Keto bread, or serve it with a crunchy and creamy slaw.

  • 4 Ingredients
  • Total Time: 8 Hours 2 Minutes
  • Diet: Dairy Free, Gluten Free, Keto, Whole30

5 – Instant Pot Pork Carnitas Recipe for Lettuce Wraps with Salsa Fresca 

carnitas recipe

A healthy take on classic pork carnitas, this pork butt recipe is great for a weeknight dinner.

Pork butt is good for a lot more than just pulled pork. Namely, these Instant Pot pork carnitas lettuce wraps with salsa fresca recipe.

If you’re trying to stick to wholesome eats, you’ll be happy to know this recipe is Paleo and Whole 30-friendly. It’s fairly low-carb too and packed with nutritious ingredients.

To start, you’ll need to make your carnitas in the Instant Pot. Rub your pork butt with a blend of dried oregano, cumin, salt, and pepper. In the Instant Pot, sear your pork butt in some avocado oil. (You may want to cut up the meat and do this in batches).

Braise the pork in a mixture of orange and lime juice, garlic, and jalapeno. Let the pressure cooker work its whip-fast magic.

You’ll serve these carnitas atop lettuce wraps with a homemade salsa fresca and hearty chunks of avocado.

  • 21 Ingredients
  • Total Time: 1 Hour 15 Minutes
  • Diet: Dairy Free, Gluten Free, Keto, Paleo, Whole30

6 – Slow-Cooker Cajun Pork Butt with Jambalaya Rice Recipe

With robust flavor and a hint of heat, Cajun spice is the perfect seasoning for pork butt. That’s why we recommend you give this slow-cooker cajun pork butt recipe with jambalaya rice a try.

As if you needed another reason to love this recipe, it’s a complete meal with the addition of the vibrant and spicy jambalaya rice.

To get started, you’ll cook up the pork butt in the slow cooker—one of the best ways to prep this cut—with Cajun spice and beef broth. Just before serving, prep your jambalaya rice, complete with multicolored bell peppers, onions, smoked paprika, Cajun spice, and, of course, long-grain rice.

Garnish the whole thing with parsley for a flavor-packed meal.

  • 13 Ingredients
  • Total Time: 4 Hours 10 Minutes
  • Diet: Dairy Free, Gluten Free

7 – Pork Butt Roast with Mushroom Gravy Recipe

We’ve been focused on pork butt recipes that result in “pulled pork” texture, and for good reason—it’s delicious. But this pork butt roast recipe with mushroom gravy mixes things up, serving up unbelievably tender slices of pork butt like a roast.

Once again, we prepare this recipe in the slow cooker, which achieves the ideal balance of low and slow cooking with plenty of moisture.

This pork butt roasts all day with garlic, thyme, dried sage, onion, cremini mushrooms, chicken broth, and bay leaves. There’s a generous dose of sea salt and pepper, too.

Once ready, you’ll use the drippings to prepare an unbelievable mushroom gravy that’s just begging for a scoop of mashed potatoes.

Check out our latest meat delivery gift boxes and choose your ButcherBox plan today!

  • 10 Ingredients
  • Total Time: 8 Hours 10 Minutes
Courtney Hamilton is a writer and editor with over seven years' experience in journalism, blogging, communications, and other media. She has written for publications like PaleoHacks, PaleoPlan, The Center for American Progress, OC Weekly, and more. 
Check out more of her work at www.courtney-hamilton.com.