pepper crusted ny strip steak recipe

Pepper Crusted NY Strip with Herb Orange Shallot Butter

Last Updated on August 29, 2022

Looking to bring a unique citrus flair to your favorite steak? This pepper-crusted NY Strip with herb orange shallot butter is a crowd pleaser and will have your guests feeling like they’re at a fine steakhouse instead of in your kitchen.

pepper crusted new york strip steak

Pepper Crusted NY Strip with Herb Orange Shallot Butter

3.89 from 9 votes
Print Pin
Protein: Beef
Cut: NY Strip Steak
Diet: Gluten Free, Keto
Course: Main Course
Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 35 minutes
Servings: 2 people


  • 2 ea ButcherBox NY Strip Steaks

Dry Rub

  • 1 Tbsp orange zest
  • ¼ tsp nutmeg
  • 2 Tbsp coarse ground black pepper
  • 1 Tbsp kosher salt

Herb Orange Shallot Butter

  • 3 ea shallots thinly sliced
  • 1 clove garlic minced
  • 1 Tbsp orange zest
  • 1 Tbsp parsley chopped
  • 1 tsp kosher salt
  • ½ tsp smoked paprika
  • 8 oz butter room temperature


Herb Orange Shallot Butter

  • Place 2 oz of butter and sliced shallots in a sauté pan. Over medium-low heat sauté until shallots are caramelized.
  • Cool shallots to room temperature and combine with remaining ingredients in food processor. Pulse to combine.
  • Place butter mixture onto a sheet of plastic wrap and roll into a tight cylinder. Refrigerate or freeze until needed.

Pepper Crusted NY Strip Steak

  • Let steaks come to room temperature. Mix dry rub together and massage onto steaks.
  • Preheat cast iron skillet on medium heat. Sear steaks 3-4 minutes per side or until internal temperature is 120℉.
  • Place healthy slice of orange butter on top of each steak and let steaks rest 5 - 8 minutes before serving. Enjoy!
Share on Pinterest!Pin at @Butcher_Box!

Yankel Polak is the Head Chef at ButcherBox.